Soul Food Cinema   
Movie Reviews and Discussion from the World's Catholic-Christian Community
  Antwone Fisher   Stand by Me   Jesus of Nazareth The Passion of The Christ Rabbit-proof Fence   Amazing Grace   Il Postino  
Homepage Suggest a film for the database 
spacer
spacer
Getting Started

About SFC

Chat Forum
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacer
Top 100 Films

Other Film Lists

Top 80 Family Films
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacer
Contact & Feedback

Questions

Resouces & Links
spacer
spacer
Search Soul Food Cinema:
spacer
spacer
spacer

 

We Were Soldiers (2002)
 
© Paramount Pictures (2002)
SFC Readers' Opinions:
(0)
(0)
(0)
SFC Reviewer's Opinion:
Limited Recommendation

Genre
Action / Drama / History / War
   
Synopsis

In a place soon to be known as 'The Valley of Death', in a small clearing called landing zone X-Ray, Lt. Colonel Hal Moore (Mel Gibson) and 400 young troops, all from an elite American combat division, were surrounded by 2,000 North Vietnamese soldiers. The ensuing battle was one of the most savage in U.S. history.

   
Directed by  
Randall Wallace
   
Written by  
Harold G. Moore (book "We Were Soldiers Once... and Young") (as Lt. Gen. Harold G. Moore); Joseph L. Galloway (book "We Were Soldiers Once... and Young"); Randall Wallace (screenplay).
   
Starring  
Mel Gibson (Lt. Col. Hal Moore); Madeleine Stowe (Julie Moore); Greg Kinnear (Maj. Bruce 'Snake' Crandall); Sam Elliott (Sgt. Maj. Basil Plumley); Chris Klein (2nd Lt. Jack Geoghegan); Keri Russell (Barbara Geoghegan); Barry Pepper (Joe Galloway); Duong Don (Lt. Col. Nguyen Huu An); Ryan Hurst (Sgt. Ernie Savage); Robert Bagnell (1st Lt. Charlie Hastings); Marc Blucas (2nd Lt. Henry Herrick); Josh Daugherty (Sp4 Robert Ouellette); Jsu Garcia (Capt. Tony Nadal); Jon Hamm (Capt. Matt Dillon); Clark Gregg (Capt. Tom Metsker). Please contact SFC to add other cast members and characters.
 

Length (mins):
138
Ratings:
R (15)
Language:
ENG

Big 5 Oscar Wins:
0
Big 5 Oscar Noms:
0
IMDB page:
Link

-
Important: the following essays and comments are authored by Soul Food Cinema readers. Whilst the Editor prays for the spiritual integrity of all content of this site, it should be noted that these represent personal opinions and carry no official endorsement. If you consider any content to be a misrepresentation of Catholic teaching, please contact SFC. May God bless you and enlighten you in your reading.
-
Articles, Essays and Reviews
-
Please contact SFC if you are interested in submitting an essay on this film.
-
Readers' Comments and Opinions
-
Click the link to comment on this film. You may like to copy the film title and year (as given above) to your clipboard now for pasting into the following form.
-
  Blood and Praying  
  Mark Banks (United Kingdom)  
  Opinion: Limited Recommendation  

The two things I'll remember about We Were Soldiers are Mel Gibson's character praying - very commendable but I felt a little misplaced; Lt. Col. Hal Moore's faith didn't seem to come much into things for the rest of the film after that, and also simply the level of blood and number of deaths after that - this truly was a harrowing and brutal battle. There was also a good level of focus on the soldiers' wives and the devastating impact hearing the news of the loss of their loved ones had on them, but overall the film lacked a true narrative to sustain any real interest and was certainly a good half hour over long too. For those with a penchant for war films, an interest in Vietnam or a fixation for all things Mel Gibson this may be worth watching, but most people would be better served watching The Longest Day, Saving Private Ryan, On the Western Front or Band of Brothers instead. One final note worth mentioning is that I didn't feel the film glamorised the violence or justified the brutality in any way, but certainly did bring home many of the true horrors of war.

 

 

spacerRecent Articles & Essays
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacerRecent Interviews
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacer
"Let us discern for ourselves what is
right; let us learn together what is good" (Job 34:4)
spacer
spacer  
spacer
spacer

 

   
 
© Copyright Soul Food Cinema 2008. Terms of quotations and reproductions.
 
Soul Food Cinema - Movie/Film Reviews and Discussion from the World's Catholic-Christian Community
Images in the header are from: Antwone Fisher (© Fox Searchlight, 2002); Stand by Me (© Columbia Pictures, 1986); Jesus of Nazareth (© ITV (1977); The Passion of The Christ (© Newmarket Films, 2004); Rabbit-proof Fence (© Buena Vista, 2002); Amazing Grace (© Bristol Bay Productions, 2006) and Il Postino (© Cecchi Gori Group, 1994).