Soul Food Cinema   
Movie Reviews and Discussion from the World's Catholic-Christian Community
  Antwone Fisher   Stand by Me   Jesus of Nazareth The Passion of The Christ Rabbit-proof Fence   Amazing Grace   Il Postino  
Homepage Suggest a film for the database 
spacer
spacer
Getting Started

About SFC

Chat Forum
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacer
Top 100 Films

Other Film Lists

Top 80 Family Films
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacer
Contact & Feedback

Questions

Resouces & Links
spacer
spacer
Search Soul Food Cinema:
spacer
spacer
spacer

 

Flags of Our Fathers & Letters from Iwo Jima (2006)

© Warner Bros (2006)
SFC Readers' Opinions:
(0)
(0)
(0)
SFC Reviewer's Opinion:
Limited Recommendation

Genre
Action / Drama / History / War
   
Synopsis

Flags of Our Fathers: February 1945. Even as victory in Europe was finally within reach, the war in the Pacific raged on. One of the most crucial and bloodiest battles of the war was the struggle for the island of Iwo Jima, which culminated with what would become one of the most iconic images in history: five Marines and a Navy corpsman raising the American flag on Mount Suribachi. The inspiring photo capturing that moment became a symbol of victory to a nation that had grown weary of war and made instant heroes of the six American soldiers at the base of the flag, some of whom would die soon after, never knowing that they had been immortalized. But the surviving flag raisers had no interest in being held up as symbols and did not consider themselves heroes; they wanted only to stay on the front with their brothers in arms who were fighting and dying without fanfare or glory. 'Flags of Our Fathers' is based on the bestselling book by James Bradley with Ron Powers, which chronicled the battle of Iwo Jima and the fates of the flag raisers and some of their brothers in Easy Company.

Letters from Iwo Jima: The island of Iwo Jima stands between the American military force and the home islands of Japan. Therefore the Imperial Japanese Army is desperate to prevent it from falling into American hands and providing a launching point for an invasion of Japan. General Tadamichi Kuribayashi is given command of the forces on the island and sets out to prepare for the imminent attack. General Kuribayashi, however, does not favor the rigid traditional approach recommended by his subordinates, and resentment and resistance fester among his staff. In the lower echelons, a young soldier, Saigo, a poor baker in civilian life, strives with his friends to survive the harsh regime of the Japanese army itself, all the while knowing that a fierce battle looms. When the American invasion begins, both Kuribayashi and Saigo find strength, honor, courage, and horrors beyond imagination.

   
Directed by  
Clint Eastwood
   
Written by  

Flags of Our Fathers: William Broyles Jr. (screenplay); Paul Haggis (screenplay); James Bradley (book); Ron Powers (book).

Letters from Iwo Jima: Iris Yamashita (screenplay); Iris Yamashita (story); Paul Haggis (story); Tadamichi Kuribayashi (book "Picture Letters from Commander in Chief"); Tsuyoko Yoshido (book "Picture Letters from Commander in Chief").

   
Starring  

Flags of Our Fathers: Ryan Phillippe (John "Doc" Bradley); Jesse Bradford (Rene Gagnon); Adam Beach (Ira Hayes); John Benjamin Hickey (Keyes Beech); John Slattery (Bud Gerber); Barry Pepper (Mike Strank); Jamie Bell (Ralph "Iggy" Ignatowski); Paul Walker (Hank Hansen). Please follow the IMDB links for full cast details.

Letters from Iwo Jima: Ken Watanabe (General Kuribayashi); Kazunari Ninomiya (Saigo); Tsuyoshi Ihara (Baron Nishi); Ryo Kase (Shimizu); Shido Nakamura (Lieutenant Ito (as Shidou Nakamura)); Hiroshi Watanabe (Lieutenant Fujita); Takumi Bando (Captain Tanida); Yuki Matsuzaki (Nozaki). Please follow the IMDB links for full cast details.

 

Length (mins):
273
Ratings:
R (15)
Language:
ENG/JAP

Big 10 Oscar Wins:
0
Big 10 Oscar Noms:
3
IMDB page:
FOF LIJ

-
Important: the following essays and comments are authored by Soul Food Cinema readers. Whilst the Editor prays for the spiritual integrity of all content of this site, it should be noted that these represent personal opinions and carry no official endorsement. If you consider any content to be a misrepresentation of Catholic teaching, please contact SFC. May God bless you and enlighten you in your reading.
-
Articles, Essays and Reviews
-
Please contact SFC if you are interested in submitting an essay on this film.
-
Readers' Comments and Opinions
-
Click the link to comment on this film. You may like to copy the film title and year (as given above) to your clipboard now for pasting into the following form.
-
  Story not strong enough to carry the films.  
  Mark Banks (United Kingdom)  
  Opinion: Limited Recommendation  
I think it’s little questioned that the technical aspects of these films really are quite good, especially with respect to the battle scenes which, post Saving Private Ryan, every director appears to want to try their hand at. My over-riding criticism of the two films though is that I just didn’t feel there was a strong enough story there in the first place. In the first film Flags of Our Fathers, the basic story lines of who was there, who wasn’t there, and we’re not the real heroes, really seemed to be stretched to breaking point. Whilst in Letters from Iowa Jima the boundaries of sentimentality were continually pushed. The use of animals twice as plot devices to show the characters’ human side showed a lack of creativity with respect to writing ability. I felt both films had a distinct air of Eastwood melancholy underlying them and both failed to establish any clear message/moral from the stories. In addition to this I felt both films were the wrong side of the two-hour mark and could have done with some editing. I like the way Mr Eastwood attempted to show both sides of the story, but I can’t help but feel it all would’ve been better to package the whole thing differently somehow.

 

 

spacerRecent Articles & Essays
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacerRecent Interviews
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacer
spacer
"Let us discern for ourselves what is
right; let us learn together what is good" (Job 34:4)
spacer
spacer  
spacer
spacer

 

   
 
© Copyright Soul Food Cinema 2008. Terms of quotations and reproductions.
 
Soul Food Cinema - Movie/Film Reviews and Discussion from the World's Catholic-Christian Community
Images in the header are from: Antwone Fisher (© Fox Searchlight, 2002); Stand by Me (© Columbia Pictures, 1986); Jesus of Nazareth (© ITV (1977); The Passion of The Christ (© Newmarket Films, 2004); Rabbit-proof Fence (© Buena Vista, 2002); Amazing Grace (© Bristol Bay Productions, 2006) and Il Postino (© Cecchi Gori Group, 1994).